Deep-rooted failures that led to the collapse of a China spy prosecution might be repeated without substantial changes, a panel of lawmakers has alerted.
Report Highlights "Disorderly" Handling
A study by the Cross-party committee on the National Security Strategy said "disorderly" mismanagement caused prosecutors discontinuing accusations against Christopher Cash and Chris Berry, who were charged with providing classified information to a China-based operative.
The two defendants continue to affirm their innocence.
"Mishandling similar subsequent trials will 'undermine public faith'," cautioned committee chair the Labour MP.
Case Collapse and Controversy
Christopher Cash, a ex- parliamentary researcher, and China-based scholar Christopher Berry, were both indicted under the espionage law in 2024.
He worked for two prominent MPs critical of China, Tom Tugendhat, then chair of the Foreign Affairs Committee, and the MP, who subsequently occupied the same position.
The prosecution service said the case fell apart after a senior government official, the deputy national security adviser (DNSA), refused to classify China an "hostile state" at the time of the reported violations.
However, the committee of MPs said they were "surprised" by the prosecution's judgment, suggesting it might have been "presented to the court".
Conclusions of the Inquiry
The panel concluded there was no "co-ordinated high-level attempt" to sabotage or impede the trial.
Rather, it was beset by "shambolic" mismanagement and "bewilderment and conflicting expectations".
- Communications between the prosecutors and ministers were "poor".
- An eight-month postponement in securing a crucial witness statement remains unexplained.
- The report also dismissed the administration's contention that comparable cases in the coming years under the new security legislation would not founder.
"The report urges the authorities to avoid characterising the failure of this case as a isolated peculiarity caused solely by old laws," the document stated.
Calls for Reform
The committee demands the government to look at implementing wide-ranging measures within a short timeframe to prevent a repeat.
- The role and responsibility of the key official — which had been left "detached and unsupported" — must be promptly assessed and restructured.
- Communications between the CPS and the government must also be "examined and improved at rapidly".
- In later cases, every national security matter must convene a official meeting within a month of indictment to pinpoint weaknesses in the evidence promptly.
- Greater "clear definition" must be given on whether government personnel are providing policy guidance or evidence.
Western commented: "Given that the global geopolitical situation worsens, delicate state security cases will arise more frequently.
"Ministers must demonstrate the citizens that it is confident in standing up to adversaries when necessary: inability to do so will sap the public's trust in our system."